“We have a president,” Jed York said yesterday. “His name is Al Guido, and I don’t make football decisions.”
This didn’t go over too well, partly because nothing the Jedster says after going 2-14 … after going 5-11 … after firing Jim Harbaugh because he was a big meanie … is going to go over well. That’s something York made fairly clear yesterday when he said “nothing I’m going to say is going to be satisfactory” three different times. But since he only faces the local media (and, by extension, the fans) once a year, the slack he’d like everyone to cut just isn’t coming his way.
However, if we’re looking at actual football maneuvering: choosing which free agents to sign, who to play, which quarterback to start, who to draft, who stays on the 53-man roster and who leaves … by all accounts, York does not meddle. That’s not to say he hasn’t suggested anything, but I’ve never heard or seen any reports of that occurring. York chooses who makes those decisions, and that obviously influences what the roster looks like every season, but let’s not confuse him with Jerry Jones or the late Al Davis.
Here’s where it gets tricky, though.
“Paraag will be with me in the interviews. We’ve certainly done research together and will be moving forward.”
Paraag Marathe. Oh, Paraag, Paraag, Paraag. We used to think Trent Baalke was bulletproof. By that measure, Marathe could survive a nuclear bomb.
He was supposedly demoted a year ago, but it appears Marathe was simply given alternate responsibilities. For example, the minor league soccer franchise in Sacramento (a city that might end up becoming a major league soccer town in the not-too-distant future). That goes along with his salary cap management and contract negotiation duties.
Tim Kawakami wrote a comprehensive column that detailed a few important things: how the 49ers are running this search in a seemingly logical way, some possible GM/coach pairings, and how Marathe fits into this equation.
Why is Marathe back on the main stage after he was banished out of the team presidency last year?
Marathe was demoted by the Yorks to try to stop the flow of leaks against Colin Kaepernick, and the leaks did indeed stop once Marathe was out of the inner circle.
But he is always a wild-card because he has that connection with Jed, and if Marathe is around, always look for other executives to get fired and Marathe to move forward when that happens.
The Yorks are very isolated from the normal NFL levels, which is why Jed almost always goes back to Marathe and why Jed communicates so often with national reporters.
I’ve been semi-joking for a bit about the possibility of Marathe becoming the team’s next GM, partly to troll fans during a Niners season that was more boring than a day of jury duty with no cell phone reception, but mostly because Dr. John York put it on the table over a decade ago when Marathe was the assistant to the general manager (the GM at the time was Terry Donahue).
“I think Paraag is clearly the salary-cap person and negotiator, I don’t think at this point in time that Paraag has the experience to be the general manager,” York said. “I think over time that he could.”
It’s been 11 years since Kevin Lynch wrote that feature on Marathe, and even someone as tone-deaf as Jed “You Don’t Dismiss Owners” York knows what kind of virtual (and maybe even literal) rioting would ensue if Marathe was named the GM this month. So I highly doubt that Jed and Marathe will lead a GM search that leads them to … Marathe. But Marathe is still around, and remains quite powerful.
While Jed has never been called a football meddler, that label has followed Marathe.
Remember when Marathe was in the booth during games and had some say in whether Mike Nolan, and later Mike Singletary, threw challenge flags?
And here’s this from Stephanie McCarroll of Niners Nation:
Marathe active game involvement is something that has been discussed in a limited manner, but has picked up a bit of steam more recently. Play calling and other football decisions – normally reserved the coaching staff – was a point of escalating tension under Nolan, Singletary and finally Jim Harbaugh’s coaching tenure. Marathe – an analytics guru and numbers cruncher – often presented mid-game suggestions for Harbaugh to go for it on fourth down, or go for two instead of kicking an extra point. At certain points, Marathe was even given a chair in the coaches booth and put in charge of replays and determining whether or not to suggest challenging questionable calls.
Marathe’s active game day role underscores one of the primary criticisms leveled at Jed York: that he and his fellow suits in the owners suite meddle too much with football decisions, and that has contributed to one of the most stunning collapses of a successful sports franchise. It also highlights the growing chasm between football strategists who rely on the growing body of analytics and statistics available versus the more old school types who remain wary of using newfangled algorithms to coach football.
Sorry to the folks at Niners Nation for the huge quotes, but there’s more:
Harbaugh has a more conservative football nature. And, he is largely driven by emotion and gut instincts. According to sources, it drove Marathe, and by extension, York and Baalke, nuts. Harbaugh resented Marathe’s meddling and often refused his counsel. Jed York and GM Trent Baalke threw their support behind Marathe, exacerbating the, by now, well documented breakdown of the relationship between Harbaugh and ownership.
That was written last November, a few days after I questioned why Marathe wasn’t getting the same kind of scrutiny for the 49ers’ decline as Jed, Baalke, or Jim Tomsula.
Many have suggested that the 49ers’ GM opening is an attractive one, including at least one of the reported candidates. ESPN’s Louis Riddick, who was drafted in the ninth round by the 49ers in 1991, said as much on TV. After considering what a GM would inherit if they accepted the 49ers’ offer — high draft picks, cap room, and a roster canvass as blank as any in the NFL with which to work — one has to wonder what might hold the 49ers back in their search. Particularly since there’s only one GM job available at the moment.
The Yorks present an obvious red flag — when times get bad, their go-to reaction is to start firing people (even if they have no viable backup plans at the time). However, annoying/unprofessional/incompetent owners have been able to lure executives with large stacks of cash on numerous occasions. Otherwise, who’d work for Dan Snyder?
It’s not like the 49ers CEO is known to be an abusive jerk, either. Actually, the fact that the Jedster seems like he’s in over his head might convince an ego-driven NFL executive type that he could kiss York’s posterior just enough to stay in good graces, while doing whatever the hell he wanted with the team after accepting a long, guaranteed contract.
But what about Marathe? He’s still there for a reason. If you’re Nick Caserio, Sean McVay, or one of the up-and-coming execs from Green Bay or Seattle (or a head coaching candidate), will York and Marathe offer you the job only if you promise to take Marathe’s draft day, cut day, and game day suggestions to heart?
The political minefield has to raise concerns as well. If you take either one of those jobs, how can you be certain that Marathe won’t persuade York to leak negative stories against you to national reporters, or go rogue and become a “league source” himself?
Many vocal fans have been crying for the Yorks to include some well-known former players, coaches and execs in their decision-making processes. While there’s no guarantee that inviting say, Joe Montana into the fold would lead to anything positive, I understand the frustration. The frustration is in large part due to Marathe. No one is questioning his intelligence. By all accounts he’s a good negotiator (just ask Colin Kaepernick’s former agents). But we know very little about him, other than he’s tight with Jed and he’s been here through everything we’ve seen since 2001. With everyone else now out of the building, the only mainstays are the Yorks and Marathe. Without knowing how much influence Marathe has, or how he’s perceived by the candidates the 49ers plan to interview, it’s difficult to experience a surge in confidence about how all of this is going to go.
Pity the poor sucker who doesn't know who Paraag is or his 12+ year history helping Jed eff up the team. Harbaugh? Harbaugh called, 9ers answered. NO credit to Jed or Marathe for having phones.
@BASportsGuy this article highlights the most troublesome part when it comes to org stability. analytics isnt the problem but knowing role
Jed and Trent hired Harbaugh, and he won with defense. Unless the retirement/injury of the four best defenders on the team, five if you count #99's implosions, can be blamed primarily on internal dysfunction that J&T are responsible for... IDK if it makes that much sense to blame them for where the team is at now. The decline of Kap, the age of Gore, Davis not putting effort in... Isn't this just a team that had an amazing defense for a few years, and a brilliant coach who could wring field goals out of an offense good enough to lose the Super Bowl?
Yes, I agree with pretty much everything BASG has said about the tactlessness of the 37-year old owner. In certain respects it seems like he's growing up in public, learning things the hard way... But if York or Baalke were to say, "Hey, this is all my fault," would that be a true statement?
It's great to see BASG taking York to task for his disingenuousness... I mean it's satisfying. But is York really any different from any other disconnected billionaire? Are there benevolent owners out there who care more about football than their bank accounts? I'm sure there are guys who make a better show of it than York, but beyond that...?
I was on Harbsugh's side in the divorce, but now I feel like perhaps York had a point: H had his chance, he couldn't seal the deal, then the defense retired, the offense went from mediocre to bad... Time to move on and rebuild.
It does suck that the stadium is in the burbs, that it's expensive and quiet. But that's a done deal, so perhaps the mourning period has expired. Do fans in NYC still complain about their stadium being in New Jersey? I mean, SF is currently populated with the same rich guys who own Santa Clara, right? So...? (I would have gone for a Candlestick rebuild, but nobody asked me.)
I'm all for a working class NFL team, but... last time I checked, the league is composed of teams that are the opposite of that. I mean, I guess working class rhetoric is good for selling $13 pints of Bud Light and $100 jerseys to people well-off enough to afford it.
I'm not sure what my point is exactly. I guess I'm wondering if we've been blaming one rich guy for stuff that's really about the economics of what must surely be the most pejoratively capitalistic sports in human history. Instead, perhaps we should blame all the rich guys. You know, the ones who retire to private islands while the players they use up and spit out hobble around with brain injuries but no health insurance.
@thekolsky most central? I assure you it's not most central. He's just a numbers guy. Lots of teams employ numbers guys.
@thekolsky evidence? Only speculation. There's as much "evidence" that he lobbied hard to keep Harbaugh.
@GoldBlooded44 thanks! any time :)
@GoldBlooded44 did you read the article? Central questn is how much input he has and whether Jed insists on him having input going forward.
@GoldBlooded44 the whole point is that most team's numbers guys don't sit in on head coach/gm interviews.
@thekolsky I'm not saying he's the right guy, but not his fault his boss doesn't understand that.
@thekolsky input on who to give gm/HC positions too is one thing (Jed trusts his judgement) its another to create rifts by interjecting
@GoldBlooded44 i really don't understand your nitpick. There's a TON of evidence that Paraag has contributed to rifts. What are you saying?
@GoldBlooded44 he's reportedly had input into play-calling and on-field strategy during games. And why does jed trust his judgment on GM/HC?
@thekolsky it's Jed's attempt to utilize analytics in FB decision making. I believe he trusts his judgement in general not specifically.
@GoldBlooded44 ok man, if you think Paraag is the right guy to help make the decision that's fine. I disagree.
@thekolsky my only nitpick is articles like that are misleading.I don't know him personally but I know his perception precedes his influence
@GoldBlooded44 and furthermore I would argue that a really quality head coach/gm combo would not want to have to take input from Paraag.
@GoldBlooded44 what is misleading? The article is simply laying out stuff that's been consistently reported.
@thekolsky Steve Kerr gets input from number geeks every day. Although his number geeks aren't in elevated positions, I'll give you that.
@thekolsky it insinuates that Paraag may potentially hamstring the new GM/HC on speculation - that's overstating and not "most central"
@GoldBlooded44 Paraag having input or not has a DIRECT effect on how appealing the jobs are.
@GoldBlooded44 it would be like if the Warriors' "number geeks" outranked both Steve Kerr and Bob Myers. It's not the way to go.
@thekolsky I'd much rather he be relegated to FC Sac but I think the toxicity starts and ends with Jed. Baalke was a snake too.
@GoldBlooded44 yeah but Jed is the owner and as he said you don't dismiss owners. Paraag is more dismissible, theoretically :)
@thekolsky He does have a cockroach resilience in that org, that's alarming. I get the speculation but I happen to have heard he's benign.
@thekolsky Anyway, thanks for the discussion. Fan of your work!
@BASportsGuy Paraag is just a numbers guy. I guess his cockroach like resilience in that organization is alarming. I assure you he's benign.
@BASportsGuy paraag should've been fired two years ago, the only reason I still think he's around is something on the down low is going on\U0001f633
@BASportsGuy I wonder if Paraag's algorithms brought us poor draft picks & the Torn ACL Crew and Coaches & GMs with differing philosophies.
@BASportsGuy Absolutely brilliant piece. We can't have any fuzzy feelings with two non-football men like Jed & Paraag still wielding power.