Bruce Bochy said yesterday that all five starting pitchers will make the Giants’ postseason roster. So barring something unforeseen, we won’t see the same situation as back in 2010 when Barry Zito was left off the playoff squad and had to contribute by being a good teammate (translation: not pouting).
That being said, not all five starters will start in the playoffs, at least not in the National League Division Series which should start at AT&T Park on Oct. 6 against either Cincinnati or Washington. Currently the Nationals have a half-game lead in the loss column and a 5-2 head-to-head record against the Reds, so there’s a better chance that the Giants face Cincinnati in the NLDS.
Which starter will become a long reliever?
We can narrow it down pretty quickly since the top three starters will be Matt Cain, Tim Lincecum and Madison Bumgarner in some order. Cain — the unquestioned ace this year — will probably start Game 1, followed by Bumgarner in Game 2 since he has been so much more successful at home (2.38 ERA, 0.42 HR/9) than on the road (4.21 ERA, 1.46 HR/9), with Lincecum starting Game 3.
Game 4 is where it gets tricky. Ryan Vogelsong is coming off his best start in a month, while Zito has pitched well in some big games throughout the course of the season. Neither pitcher performed well in August, but Zito has been better in September.
Here is how each pitcher fared in 2012 against the Reds and Nationals:
Vogelsong vs. Cincinnati (4/26, 7/1): 13 IP, 4.15 ERA, 10 H, 10 K, 3 BB, 2 HR
Vogelsong vs. Washington (8/13): 2.2 IP, 27.00 ERA, 9 H, 5 K, 2 BB, 0 HR
Zito vs. Cincinnati (4/25, 6/30): 12 IP, 1.50 ERA, 10 H, 7 K, 8 BB, 1 HR
Zito vs. Washington: N/A
In looking at the Reds’ and Nationals’ splits vs. left-handed and right-handed starters, there is virtually no difference.
***
Here’s where the “Amici’s Playoff Party” contest comes in…
You may have noticed the ads on BASG — we’re proud to announce a partnership deal with Amici’s East Coast Pizzeria for many reasons. First, the food is great. My wife and I have ordered their cheese and veggie pies in the past week and they were both delicious. Second, Amici’s East Coast Pizzeria (like BASG) is a Bay Area based company started by two people who are passionate about what they do and invested in the community. Third, Amici’s East Coast Pizzeria doesn’t enter into partnerships like these lightly, and I’m sure most of you reading know exactly how loyal they are to the people they work with.
Here’s how you can win an Amici’s Playoff Pizza Party for 20 at your home:
Every day this week we’ll be running an “Amici’s Playoff Party” post where you can comment for your chance to win.
Readers can enter daily — the more you comment, the higher your chances are to win a Playoff Pizza Party for 20 from Amici’s East Coast Pizzeria. There will be a random drawing on Saturday to select winner.
TODAY’S COMMENT TOPIC: WHO DO YOU WANT TO START GAME 4 — ZITO OR VOGELSONG?
Good luck!














49ers Hot Read
49ersnews.com
49erswebzone.com
Niner Insider
Athletics Nation
95.7 FM The Game
Bay Area Sports Talk
Popblerd
Ray Ratto – CSNBA
Ruthless Sports
Giants Extra
Giants Talk
Giants365.com
GiantsPod
Optioned to Fresno
Fangraphs
Pro Football Talk
Feltbot's Warriors Blog
Joe Lacob & Co. [libelous slander]
WarriorsCentral.com

Vogelsong will be used for relief, Zito as a starter
I think it is a tough decision,but Vogelsong has struggled a lot lately,even though he did just have a quality start.I see Vogeltron not starting in the first round of the playoffs
I'm gonna go Vogelsong.
Gotta go with Zeeeto. He's earned it and Vogie has been bad over the last month or so.
Zito, but Vogelsong will be an option immediately should Zito under-perform.
Zitelsong
Vogelsong.
Vogelsong
Tim Lincecum
Zito. By the way, the meatballs at Amici's are great!
Zito with Vogelsong first out of the pen.
"the more you comment, the higher your chances are to win" So should we just declare Stan the winner now? Zito will most likely start since its known he doesn't do well coming out of the bullpen.
And And I should ask for royalty's if you or Slam win anything.
Or Reg..or.darn too many to remember.
Give me Zeets!
Yep, Zito. I feel like he will come out there with something to prove.
I think in the playoffs,any team that bares down on Zito will do better then if they bore down on Vogelsong. Zito can't EVER throw 90's. A patient team not only could rout Zito,but wear out the Giants bullpen. But..Zito this year is heavier,has larger arms and a turkey neck if you look for it. "Supplements"..well,isnt that always the case of bad then better older?..same for Vogy...but he at least takes it to a higher level. Zito..just better then what he's been.
I agree with Stan! :)
Thanks Super Sports Girl! And I looooove pizza..and know 20 people who do too! Or, I could be totally selfish and freeze so much Pizza I would be like a Twilight Zone episode of the last guy on Earth..with Pizza,who cares if my glasses break??..hee.
It's your pizza party and you can eat all the pizza if you want to!
Zito. Zito getter better and better the more distance he gets from having that "show" with Urban. Better "particles" with Pauley Mac's "75, 75" LOL
No 4th starter needed in NLDS...the Giants will sweep the 1st round. Though if there is a 4th game...1. Cain 2. Mad Bum 3. Lincecum 4. Zito gets the start, goes 3.2 innings, then Vogey comes in for long relief.
Either Stan doesn't like pizza or his internet is out today. Zito goes Game 4. Too bad too, because Vogelsong was fantastic in the first half
Zito will be given the starting spot because of his numbers as well as his need for a long warm up session. Voglesong's numbers recently are too much to gamble on.
Vogey... Zito has had a great year but I'm counting on Vogelsong in the clutch.
Zito. He's earned it and Vogelsong can be the long reliever or serve another bullpen function.Hell, he can even get a start in the next round.
Zito. When he's on, no one is hitting him. However, he's not the kind of pitcher that should be put in for an inning of relief here or there, sometimes it takes him a bit longer to get comfortable on the mound. Vogey, although he's been slipping since the All-Star break, is still a strong starter and had a good start against the Padres on Friday. Although I don't know if that's enough to earn him a starting spot. I do think he would be great in the bullpen, he could be a great long reliever if any of the starters begin to look shaky. Plus, Bochy likes to alternate lefties and righties so I'm sure he'd prefer 2 of each in the starting rotation.
I say Zito makes the rotation on a short leash with Vogey the long man.
Vogey. better stuff, better true talent.
Game 1: Cainer Game 2: Bum Game 3: Timmy (w/ Vogey as long-man is the proverbial shit hits the fan). Game 4: Zito (w/ Vogey if he didn't pitch in Game 3). I think Hensley gets left off roster for Everyday Kontos.
*Game 3: Timmy (w/ Vogey as long-man if the proverbial shit hits the fan).
Vogey has better stuff to come out of the bullpen and get people out.
I'm hesitant to say it, but given the numbers, I've gotta go with Zito.
Zito - comeback pitcher of the year. He deserves it and he's got the drive to make-up for what he missed in 2010. Go Zitooooo!!!