Bill Walsh

Does Bill Walsh deserve blame for the 49ers’ past decade of futility?

By Guest Contributor Scott Warfe

The turn of the century was a time of transition. The nation was making a binary jump from 99 to 00. I too was making a numerical leap of my own, equally uncertain and weird. I was turning 16. These uncertainties and oddities were codified by a nation and its constituents as moments of great transformation.

The 49ers transformation, while certainly strange and uncertain, was more death than rebirth. Sparked by brother Eddie’s felony charge, Denise DeBartolo York effectually banned Eddie from 49ers football, taking complete control of the 49ers in 1999 (almost a year after Eddie’s conviction). Though the Age of Eddie has been canonized by 49er fans, the team that John York inherited was one marked by scandal and chaos.

Carmen Policy and Dwight Clark had run the team into the ground. In 2000, the NFL Management Council found that Policy and Clark had violated the CBA in negotiating contracts with Steve Young, Brent Jones, and others. The most egregious of these violations involve former first round pick Jim Druckenmiller. Druckenmiller’s rookie contract included a loophole that allows a team to prorate a signing bonus over six years against the cap, even though the sixth year was guaranteed to be voided. What’s more, according to Peter King, Clark “made a verbal side deal with Druckenmiller’s agent promising him that the first-round pick’s contract would be renegotiated within three years if Druckenmiller were to become a starter during that time.”

Policy and Clark never admitted their guilt, and ended up settling with the Management Council: Policy was fined $400,000 and Clark, $200,000. The 49ers too were disciplined as a result of the Policy and Clark’s improprieties. The team was fined $300,000 and had to surrender their fifth pick in the 2001 draft and their third pick in 2002.

Ultimately, although the 49ers would only suffer from the Druckenmiller negotiation misconduct for the proceeding two seasons, it was drafting Druckenmiller that would set them back for a decade and more.

Prior to the 1997 NFL Draft, the 49ers had recognized the need to find a quarterback who would take the reigns from an aging Steve Young. To ensure success in this matter, the team commissioned Bill Walsh to identify a successor. Walsh would eventually find his man, and the 49ers would draft the strong-armed Jim Druckenmiller with the 26th overall pick.

Sixteen picks later, the Arizona Cardinals would select the man Walsh wanted: Jake Plummer.

There proved to be one to many hands stirring the pot. According to Mike Silver, “Carmen Policy and Dwight Clark and Vinny Cerrato were the driving forces behind the decision to take Druckenmiller.” Policy et al were convinced that “Druck”—as they called him—had “the most ability, the strongest arm, the most poise in the pocket and the best ability to read second and third receivers.” Meanwhile, all Plummer had was an endorsement from Walsh, who believed Plummer would have “Montana like career, including the Super Bowls.”

Unfortunately for the franchise and its fans, this wouldn’t be the last time Walsh would be vetoed. It would happen again in 2000.

In 1998, Plummer would lead the talent-challenged Arizona Cardinals to the playoffs for the first since 1947. In 1999, Policy and Clark would take executive positions with the Cleveland Browns, and York, saddled with a crippling cap situation and no successor for Young, would tab Walsh as General Manager, giving him autonomous control.

Walsh’s second stint as GM would not go as smoothly as his first. In fact, his first off-season was marked by great players lost, not found.

Handcuffed by the cap, Walsh would lose myriads of starters, including Pro Bowl guard Kevin Gogan, Roy Barker (12 sacks in 1998), Merton Hanks, Marquez Pope, and Antonio Langham. And, what’s more, the ’99 draft proved unsuccessful.

The ’99 season would go no better for Walsh. Following a season in which the 49ers would lose 12 games and Steve Young, Walsh was attempting to redeem his dubious tenure. There was no better place to do that than the NFL Draft.

Walsh started auspiciously, parlaying the 3rd overall pick into the 16th, 24th, 48th, and 86th overall picks. He would not only seek to shore up their awful defense, but also find a long-term solution at quarterback. Going into the draft, pundits had Chad Pennington pegged to be the 49ers’ quarterback of the future, but the 49ers had somebody else in mind: Giovanni Carmazzi.

As with Druckenmiller, it is believed that Walsh had little to do with this decision. Ira Miller believes that Walsh was “simply deferring to the coaches.” Those coaches — Steve Mariucci and Greg Knapp — were, according to Miller, “high” on Carmazzi.

Despite Seattle’s Offensive Coordinator Gil Haskell’s negative scouting report—in which he noted that “it was like [Carmazzi] never played” — the 49ers drafted him with the 65th overall pick.

Three rounds and 134 picks later, the Patriots would select San Mateo’s Tom Brady.

Walsh-the-General-Manager/Consultant, as it seems, was again vetoed. However, unlike in 1997, the problem in 2000 was not due to a lack of control. To the contrary, it was the result of the control he had. Walsh vetoed himself because, as Miller pointed out, Walsh-the-Head-Coach loathed the “notion that a general manager could pick the players for someone else to coach.” And so, Carmazzi happened.

The following season would be Walsh’s last. He would leave the team in the hands of Terry Donahue, a man whom Walsh handpicked as his successor.

In all, Walsh’s second coming was like the Y2k scare and being 16: it was more hype than substance. His drafts were unfruitful, his free agent signings were ineffective (except Garcia and Garner), and his handpicked replacement was inept.

So, does Walsh deserve the blame for the 49ers’ past decade of futility? I don’t know, but I do know that John York doesn’t deserve it. Click here to find out why.

In addition to blogging on Posttraumaticsportsdisorder.com, Scott has been featured onOregonSportsNews.comSickoftheRadio.com, and Examiner.com. Follow him on Twitter@ScottWarfe.

10 Comments

Leave a Reply

10 Comments on "Does Bill Walsh deserve blame for the 49ers’ past decade of futility?"

Notify of
avatar
 
smilegrinwinkmrgreenneutraltwistedarrowshockunamusedcooleviloopsrazzrollcryeeklolmadsadexclamationquestionideahmmbegwhewchucklesillyenvyshutmouth
Photo and Image Files
 
 
 
Audio and Video Files
 
 
 
Other File Types
 
 
 
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
Stan
Guest
Member
Stan

I dunno- I heard he never considered Brady AND I heard he mentioned that kid Brady..Legends are built like that.

DW
Guest
Member
DW

So we’re throwing a dead guy under the bus??

Scott
Guest
Member

I had envisioned it more like a “Weekend at Bernie’s” scenario.

devnull
Guest
Member
devnull
I disagree w/your thesis in [link] that York is blameless for the last decade. Walsh certainly had his share of the mis-steps over that period while acting as GM and/or consultant, but: [from link] “Donahue selected Monte Kiffin, but would get eventually settle on Dennis Erickson after Kiffin turned the team down.” Erickson was a very large mistake, and the path for it leads from Donahue to York. You can argue (with some validity) that Walsh is to blame for Donahue, but Dr. John York was acting as owner and decision-making authority, so hiring Donahue wouldn’t have happened if he… Read more »
Scott
Guest
Member

True. It was under York’s watch. But, still, York new very little about football. The job was, after all, foisted on him by circumstance. After two years of Donahue/Erickon’s ineptitude, York fired him. That is pretty swift action.

devnull
Guest
Member
devnull
“After two years of Donahue/Erickon’s ineptitude, York fired him.” … and replaced Erickson with Mike Nolan. Full marks for firing Donahue, though. Shame he was ever hired in the first place. “But, still, York new very little about football.” This much is true. “The job was, after all, foisted on him by circumstance.” Maybe, though one could argue (as you did in your article) that his wife orchestrated the “circumstance”; and regardless, he hardly seemed bothered by it. On the contrary: considering how York continued to fiddle with the team, in spite of knowing very little about football, it appears… Read more »
Scott
Guest
Member
I agree with you. He deserves the blame for Nolan. But, I don’t see the Nolan years as all that bad. That is, the Nolan Era was a transitional period. Team was able to accumulate talent, as well as install the structure from which Baalke would rise to prominence. In all, York took over a team that was in really bad shape. Though it took quite a long time, I think the team is position to sustain success because of the structure he helped create. Consider a team like the Dolphins. Parcells was hired as President, and he seemed to… Read more »
devnull
Guest
Member
devnull
Nolan was 18-37 as Niners coach — I think that’s a little worse than “transition period”. It was arguably getting worse at the end, before he was finally fired mis-season. I wanted the Nolan thing to work out — I was rooting for him at the beginning. But I think his suit distraction and the way he treated his players were damaging. Probably Nolan wasn’t ready for head coaching duty then, and he definitely wasn’t ready for a GM role; giving him both was a mistake. “So, yes, York is responsible for the 49ers recent failures, but he’s also responsible… Read more »
Ralph's Future Unemployment Check
Guest
Member
Ralph's Future Unemployment Check
The problems of the last decade was OWNERSHIP hiring boobs and making them head coach. Dennis Erickson? Only thing he could coach professionally is a drinking team. Mike Nolan? Right hire in 2005, but it was clear after three seasons that he was not head coach material, yet one more season was wasted by bringing him back then firing him once the season was pretty much over already. Mike Singletary? Caught up in the hype of the fans getting excited when ownership of all people should have been objective in looking at his actual ability as a head coach. Talent… Read more »
trackback
Member

[…] Does Bill Walsh deserve blame for the 49ers&#8217 ; past decade of futility (BayAreaSportsGuy.com) […]

wpDiscuz
What is Bay Area Sports Guy?

It is the top independent sports site covering the teams that play in the best sports region in the United States. BASG is not an ordinary fan blog. It is a place where sports news is broken and analyzed by writers with access who are not afraid to question the status quo, writers who also produce original content in the form of videos, photographs and podcasts.

Questions/Comments? Email basg@bayareasportsguy.com
Fill out my online form.

Copyright © 2017 - Bay Area Sports Guy. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy Terms of Use and BASG Shop Terms

To Top