Giants not lovin' McDonald, not not lovin' Greinke

In the Battle of Snubs, James McDonald reigned supreme. Winning his fourth straight victory, McDonald struck out 10 batters. Actually, embarrassed would  be the more fitting verb. Giants hitters looked absolutely lost today, especially Pablo Sandoval and Brandon Belt.

McDonald clearly has the Giants number. Back on April 13th, McDonald’s two-out single in the sixth inning broke up Matt Cain’s otherwise perfect game. Cain didn’t allow another base-runner for the rest of that game.

But it’s not just the Giants who McDonald is tormenting. It’s the entire league.

For giggles, lets compare McDonald’s stats to Matt Cain’s.

Cain 120.1 8.83 1.80 2.62 3.13 3.55
McDonald 110.0 8.18 2.54 2.37 2.98 3.60


Despite the career year, it is really no surprise that McDonald was not selected to the All-Star Game. For one, he pitches for the Pittsburgh Pirates, playing for the people of Pennsylvania. Joey McMurry already explained why small market teams are at a disadvantage when it comes to All-Star games.

It is mostly unsurprising because McDonald was pretty bad last year. Unless they’re a knuckle-baller, one-year wonders don’t typically make the All-Star Game. Feel free to prove me wrong in the comments section.

Speaking of proving me wrong, commenter Adam did just that on the 4th of July. In my eagerness to construct a heat-related metaphor for Lincecum’s struggles, I overlooked one thing: Lincecum struggles are not heat induced.

What do these charts mean? Well, in Adam’s words, “there is practically no correlation between the temperature and his ERs or game score (an R squared of 0 means there is actually no correlation).”

Tomorrow, game-time temperatures are predicted to be in high 80s, low 90s. That’s not entirely too bad, but there is supposed to be 61% humidity. I’m sweating just thinking about that. We’ll see how Lincecum fairs.

Stolen BASGs

–The Giants’ new rotation will feature Lincecum between Madison Bumgarner and Matt Cain, according to Alex Pavlovic. The order of the final two spots has not been decided yet.

–Hat tip to @GiantsNirvana for this tidbit. Scouts from several teams, the Giants included, were up in arms over Zach Greinke’s ejection from Saturday’s match up against Detroit.

Apparently, the Giants are in the market for a starting pitcher. Who knew? Even with Lincecum’s struggles, I though the rotation was etched in stone. It might not even matter, as Jon Heyman believes the Braves and Orioles are the favorites to land Grienke.

–Finally, since I ended yesterdays post-game notes with a cute video, I thought I’d continue the trend. This isn’t as cute as baby Pandas, but it’s Buster Posey, so…

Leave a Reply

3 Comments on "Giants not lovin' McDonald, not not lovin' Greinke"

Photo and Image Files
Audio and Video Files
Other File Types
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Paperback Writer
Paperback Writer

Re: Alex P’s report that Timmy will be between Cain and Bum in the rotation and “Not sure about 4th 5 th spots…..REALLY?! LOL

Ok – let’s work this out, LOL… 1 Cain 2 Tim 3 Bum
Hum, Zito Vogie , Zito, Vogie 4 , 5, 5, , 4. Um give me a break! If the 1st part of the report is true, it’s gotta be 4 Vogelson, 5 Zito


Hearing this mornings Yahoo sports..where the host said he understood hick city’s will try to get one of their own…even though “David Wright deserved to be an all star and not Pablo Sandoval”,he didn’t say Panda. But it was 100% stereotype New York, east coast bias, fast talking used car salesmen speil.


I think Adam needs to do a real world chart…Lincecum has no doubt struggled in heat all through his career..and its just been made worse this year. I would say his only four good games were pitched in under 80F weather.
And his other bad year? -the first half of 2010. Maybe Adams charts are skewed by Lincecums good years or months…when he had put on weight. Check the temps when’s been “too thin Tim”….

What is Bay Area Sports Guy?

It is the top independent sports site covering the teams that play in the best sports region in the United States. BASG is not an ordinary fan blog. It is a place where sports news is broken and analyzed by writers with access who are not afraid to question the status quo, writers who also produce original content in the form of videos, photographs and podcasts.

Questions/Comments? Email
Fill out my online form.

Copyright © 2017 - Bay Area Sports Guy. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy Terms of Use and BASG Shop Terms

To Top