Hey Giants, Andrew McCutchen may be available

Photo credit: Mangin Photography

It’s a good thing I’m writing this about Andrew McCutchen, since the Giants would surely have no idea otherwise. Who reads Jon Morosi, anyway?

OK, so the Giants are probably well aware that McCutchen is a player they could (and should … duh) target. He’s only making $14 million in 2017, with a $14.5 million team option ($1 million buyout) for 2018. He was a top-five MVP finalist for four straight years (2012-15), winning the award in 2013 when he finished with over eight wins above replacement (according to Baseball-Reference and Fangraphs).

He’s also coming off his worst season, one in which his defense declined and he was benched for the Pirates’ first three games in August. He still finished with 24 home runs — seven more than Brandon Belt — but he probably isn’t a great defensive center fielder anymore and he struck out more (but not that much more) than ever before.

It’s hard to believe the Giants (or several other teams, including ones like the Mariners and Nationals who reportedly tried to pry McCutchen away from Pittsburgh) could buy low on McCutchen. And it they probably can’t, if we’re being realistic — it would probably take more than the Giants were comfortable parting with in a trade, even if they’re guaranteed that McCutchen won’t regress after turning 30 last month.

But the Giants are certainly interested in dealing for moderately-priced outfielders who can hit, as we all saw when they reportedly discussed a deal with the Tigers for J.D. Martinez. Martinez is a year younger than McCutchen and a year removed from a 38-homer season. Like McCutchen, Martinez had a down year defensively in 2016, except Martinez’s poor defensive metrics came as a right fielder instead of a center fielder. It’s not controversial to suggest that McCutchen is a superior defensive player. And given McCutchen’s MVP credentials, acquiring Martinez would be far less painful in terms of prospects surrendered.

Given the Giants’ relative lack of worry about center field defense — which seems really weird to type since the franchise’s best player was Willie Mays — they’d probably be more than fine with McCutchen playing center whenever Denard Span needed a breather. Or even replacing Span with McCutchen in center if Span got hurt during Spring Training or something.

What are the other options for a team that probably shouldn’t roll into 2017 with the Mac Williamson/Jarrett Parker combo as their left field Plan A?

  • They could trade for Ryan Braun, who has $80 million in guaranteed money coming to him and was in the news several times for PED allegations (and a 65-game suspension) a few years ago.
  • They could sign a third baseman and move Eduardo Nuñez to left field.
  • Like Martin Prado, the leading vote-getter among Marty Lurie callers suggesting midseason trade targets for the Giants (for at least three years running).
  • Or Justin Turner.
  • Or they could bore everyone and sign Luis Valbuena or Trevor Plouffe.
  • They could sign Dexter Fowler, who I thought they should’ve targeted a year ago.
  • They could go crazy and sign Jose Bautista, someone they’d probably need to overpay to convince him to come to a HR-suppressing park like AT&T.

Turner, Fowler and Bautista got qualifying offers. So did Kenley Jansen, which is why I think the Giants’ desired offseason closers are probably ranked like this:

  1. Mark Melancon
  2. Brad Ziegler
  3. Greg Holland (Holland and Ziegler could probably switch places)

I don’t think they’d want to deal with spending over $50 million on Aroldis Chapman considering a sizable portion of the fanbase would loudly protest. (Besides, who wants to spend a ton of money and spend the first press conference answering newspaper columnists’ questions about domestic violence?) Jansen is going to cost more than Melancon, who isn’t as intimidating in terms of stuff but might be a better option in terms of production per dollars spent.

Looks like I got distracted with the whole closer thing, which makes sense since the Giants came out and said it was their top priority of the offseason.

Let’s not ignore these McCutchen rumors, though. He was the most exciting player I saw in person during the 2013 season, and he would immediately make the Giants a lot more exciting in 2017 even if he regresses a little (and from August until the end of the season he was pretty good: .284/.381/.471). Plus, the Giants seem to have pretty good luck when they make deals with Pittsburgh. Does that mean the Giants should trade Tyler Beede, Ty Blach, Panik and Arroyo for McCutchen? No, but the Giants should at least call the Pirates and see what they’d be asking.*

*There’s about a 99.8% chance they’ve already called the Pirates about McCutchen.


No freakin' way... WRONG, WRONG, WRONG... McCutchen hasn't had an "off year", he has imploded. His drop off in metrics is unprecedented. Literally, unprecedented! This is such an incredible risk to take. Calling the Pirates to find out what they want is fine but they are going to try and milk all the talent out of a trade that they can. How many talented future Giants are you willing to part with to find out if McCutchen can return to form? I'm not willing to part with any for this experiment!!!!

The solution is to get a guy who is a current free agent, which will cost exactly ONE draft pick. Oh by the way, there is a guy who is at the top of his game right now, who is a solid hitter and a plus fielder... Yoenis Cespedes is the guy we need!!! It will cost some money to get him but this move isn't an experiment. Picking up Cespedes improves the Giants offense and defense right now and doesn't cost us players already in the system. As far as the loss of a first round draft pick goes... Whoever it would have been will most likely never be as good as Cespedes... especially considering how low the Giants draft pick will be.


I really like the idea of having a left fielder who can also play center and bats right with power to bat fourth. This would also help keep both Parker and Mac on the roster. Pirates will wait until trade deadline to see if he builds up value. Ian Desmond is another option, but not sure if I'd want to gamble on a four yr contract. McCutchen would cost a lot, but I'd love to see him in a Giants uniform. I'd like the Giants to sign Melancon for 4yrs ~55 mil. and wait and see how Mac/Parker do, then go after McCutchen at trade deadline if needed.

Otis Byrd III
Otis Byrd III

Getting McCutchen would be awesome, but I highly doubt the Giants trade for him. The Pirates know the Giants need an outfielder, and they might try to raise up the asking price for him.

Having McCutchen in this lineup would be awesome. He could leadoff or bat 3rd. The Giants could have him in CF and move Span to LF.

But yes, as awesome as this would be, I highly doubt the Giants do something like this.


this is what happens when you have space to fill and nothing to write about


I think I'm distracted by the closer situation too (plus the rest of the bullpen for that matter).  If McCutchen is there for the asking then sure, go for it.  But don't lose sight of the pitching staff.


@BASportsGuy think about how well it went the last time the G's signed a Pirate free agent

What is Bay Area Sports Guy?

It is the top independent sports site covering the teams that play in the best sports region in the United States. BASG is not an ordinary fan blog. It is a place where sports news is broken and analyzed by writers with access who are not afraid to question the status quo, writers who also produce original content in the form of videos, photographs and podcasts.

Questions/Comments? Email

Sign up for our mailing list.

Copyright © 2016 - Bay Area Sports Guy. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy Terms of Use and BASG Shop Terms

To Top