NFL

How to bring the 49ers back …

Jed York 49ers

(Extended headline) … to respectability, not San Francisco.

It’d be foolish to say the 49ers will NEVER return to The City, but if that happened it would be after most of us are long gone. No, this is a post containing an idea or two that would somehow remedy this horribly mismanaged franchise.

The game yesterday? Psssshhhh. No point in spending any time analyzing that. It was good for the 49ers that they lost, but that’s about it. Colin Kaepernick was the most dynamic player on the field for the visiting team (which, somewhat surprisingly, played noticeably hard for 60 minutes). Kaepernick was the team’s best rusher and, while he threw a few passes that were Gabbsolutely dreadful, he also threw several dimes that we weren’t expecting to see from him this year, or perhaps ever again.

But as I’ve written before, Kaepernick is doing his best to launch himself to a new team and a better situation. And once Kaepernick becomes a New York Jet (the most likely option if I had to guess), the 49ers will be left sitting with a roster completely devoid of star power. Not that Kaepernick has looked like a star since three years ago, but the overall boringness of this roster is astounding. And stars change the entire dynamic, as we’re seeing in Oakland.

So that’s why, as I start listing options for the Yorks heading into next year and beyond, I’m going to list the worst-case scenario first and get progressively more optimistic from there.

Option 1 (total disaster): Trent Baalke stays, Chip Kelly goes

This move would be a signal that the Yorks are pleased with Baalke’s performance and will keep cycling through coaches who fail with his crappy rosters for years as 49ers tickets go for $1.99 on the secondary market. Who would Baalke target to replace Kelly? Tom Coughlin? Bill Parcells? The corpse of Tom Landry? It’s impossible to imagine any ambitious, semi-young head coaching candidate happily agreeing to work with Baalke after what has occurred in Santa Clara over the last few years.

If this scenario unfolds, 49ers fans should just give up, at least temporarily. I’m not joking. Flip sides and root for the Raiders to knock off teams like the Patriots, Cowboys and Seahawks. Stop watching the NFL altogether. Pick a college team if you don’t already have one, and invest your time and emotion into that squad instead. My wife went to Washington, and being a college free agent when we met (I went to UC Santa Cruz, which concerned itself more with ultimate frisbee and hacky-sack than football when I attended), I dove in and became a Huskies fan. After several years of watching average-to-slightly-above-average football, I’m finally reaping the benefits this season. It can happen to you, too!

If you’re a “Niner 4 Lyfe” and can’t stomach the thought of changing that part of your being, you’re going to go through a lot of pain if ownership hasn’t already realized that Baalke is a joke of a general manager who’s been stockpiling “upside” guys for years. His strategy has produced a roster incapable of building leads or coming back from deficits, as well as some of the most boring football in the history of the organization. And it’s up to ownership to remove him from his post to prove they’re actually watching the games.

Option 2 (drowning in place): Trent Baalke and Chip Kelly stay

Option 3 (last-ditch attempt to save face): Trent Baalke goes, Chip Kelly stays

This seemed like the likeliest option when the season started, because the Yorks spent a decent amount on Kelly. Plus, at the beginning of this year Jed said, “Look, Chip’s going to be here for a long time, period.”

And if you can’t take Jed York at his word …

/spit take

//wipes coffee from computer screen and keyboard

Ahem.

Here’s the problem (if you think Kelly is the best coach out there, something many observers don’t believe): a new GM would almost certainly want to choose the next head coach. So this option only works if Jeddy Y. replaces Trader Trent with Tommy Gamble, who’s tight with Chippy K.

OR, York targeted a potential general manager from outside the organization who legitimately wanted to work with Kelly, which would probably point to one of two things.

  1. The new GM was desperate for the position and would do anything to placate Jed.
  2. The new GM is too close with Kelly, who would probably assume more power over the roster than he deserves after the train wreck that unfolded in Philly.

I don’t know enough about Gamble — who’s supposedly tight with Trader Trent as well — to know whether he can steer the 49ers out of this. I assume Option 3 will lead to more of the same misery for the 49ers, but it’s preferable to seeing Baalke remain in his role of Chief Drafter of Long-Armed Projects Who’ll Get Extensions They Don’t Deserve.

Option 4 (I have no idea if this would work but it sure sounds better than the first three): Give the team to David Shaw

If Jed wanted to actually win with class instead of talking about it, making Shaw the head coach and giving him full power over personnel could be the right move. COULD BE. Shaw has nine years of NFL coaching experience and he’s shown the ability to keep Stanford relevant in times both good and lean. But he probably wouldn’t leave Stanford unless the Yorks handed him the entire operation, and many smart men have failed when tasked with doing every … single … thing.

Still intriguing, though.

Option 5 (my crazy idea that’ll never happen): The Full Shanahan

What could this organization use? It’s a long list, so bear with me.

  • A franchise quarterback and more talent on both sides (but especially at the skill positions)
  • An innovative coaching staff with a track record of success in the NFL
  • A GM who understands that creating a team is more about finding pieces that work in concert with one another than simply accumulating assets that may or may not pan out at a later date
  • A president of FOOTBALL — as opposed to BUSINESS (i.e. tickets sales and Coldplay shows, or minor league soccer teams) — operations who supervises, advises and oversees everything and everyone, from general manager to equipment manager (in other words, Jed needs his own John McVay/Carmen Policy)
  • And, subjectively, a reminder that they don’t need to mix-and-match philosophies from other organizations when the 49ers were the most brilliant and innovative team in the NFL for almost two decades

As you can probably surmise, my crazy idea that’ll never happen is to hire Kyle Shanahan as the head coach. As for his father, Mike, we’re going to make him the President of Football Operations. His job will be to create a team in his vision, hire a GM, and fight the Yorks to get his son whatever he needs to propel the 49ers to a level where they can start winning division titles and contending for Super Bowls again.

The elder Shanahan isn’t so old that he couldn’t possibly serve as GM, but at 64 his experience (he was V.P. of football operations in Washington) and knowledge is better suited for a role that doesn’t necessarily entail flying across the country multiple times each month. Bringing Mike Shanahan aboard would also create a connection with the times that made the franchise and everyone who roots for it so proud, without forcing Jed to look like he’s blatantly copying his uncle (Shanahan was only with the 49ers as their offensive coordinator from 1992-94).

Totally sentimental side benefit alert!

You know what would come with Mike, right? Instead of Trent Dilfer being the 49ers’ top surrogate on ESPN, that title would move to Steve Young. Anyone who makes a habit of listening to Young’s fantastic interviews with Tom Tolbert knows how much he credits Shanahan with his success. I’ll always remember what Young said about Kaepernick’s development a year ago.

“Think about what happened in the offseason. (Kaepernick) had been working — every year I’d hear ‘I’m getting stronger, I’m getting faster.’ Those are the things he’s great at. He’s great at that.

“And this year it’s more different. ‘I’m going to work on some of the more softer skills.’ Well, it’s still hardware. Right? I’m going to work on my release. I’m going to work on my footwork. All important, super important stuff.

“But the stuff I’m talking about is way more tedious than that. I keep using that word because it’s boring. Middle of April, in the back room, just kind of going through it over and over. It’s Mike Shanahan, drive you crazy going through it.

“‘Let’s go through it again.’

“‘No, Mike, I literally cannot go through it again.’

“‘But Steve, if you don’t go through it again, and get it deep into your brain, it won’t reflex back out. You’ll have to think about it for a second, and it’s too long. Too late. And then if you start to get all the stuff now embedded into you, you can start to dictate terms.'”

The 49ers could certainly use that kind of attention to detail.

As for Mike’s son, just look at the Falcons. They’re leading the league in points, yards per play and yards per pass attempt (8.2). Sure, they have Julio Jones … which helps. A lot. But they also throw passes to their running backs that actually work in situations other than “it’s 3rd-and-15 and we need to get a little better field position, so let’s dump it off to Draughn or Hyde.” And Matt Ryan, who has tantalized/frustrated Falcons fans for years, is playing the best football of his career by far. (Ryan currently has a quarterback rating of 114.3. His career high is 99.1 in 2012.)

“He’s extremely smart and extremely competitive,” said one high-ranking official from a rival team who knows Shanahan well. “He learned a lot from the Washington and Cleveland experiences. He’s got a good mind for putting players in positions to succeed and using them to their strengths.” One of his former quarterbacks echoed the sentiment, calling Shanahan a “very smart guy. Always has his mind on football.”

Kyle has finally broken through the dreaded nepotism label that followed him through prior stops, something Jed would probably like to discard as well.

The Falcons are 7-4, with a head coach in Dan Quinn who used to serve as the defensive coordinator in Seattle. Atlanta is 28th in points allowed and 27th in yards allowed. So Kyle Shanahan — now in his ninth year as an offensive coordinator at age 36 — is going to be in high demand after this season. If the 49ers are going to get him as their replacement for Kelly, they’re going to need to provide more than a market value salary and some flattering words. He’s going to require some assurances that he’ll have the best personnel staff in football to make his life easier.

It’s not like he and Shaw are the only head coaching candidates out there. Washington’s offensive coordinator, Sean McVay, is an up-and-comer. Josh McDaniels has been mentioned several times, although it’s beyond me why he’d want to come to Santa Clara unless he was also given personnel control — no thanks to that. Maybe if the 49ers hired Scott Pioli as their GM, but he’s currently the asst. GM in Atlanta — it might make more sense for the Yorks to make Pioli their GM and have him report to Shanahan the Elder.

This scenario I’ve listed last (meaning it has my stamp of approval, whatever that’s worth … probably nothing) — hiring Mike Shanahan as the President of Football Operations, Pioli (or Mike Shanahan’s first choice, if Pioli isn’t it) as GM, and Kyle Shanahan as head coach — would cost a lot of money and force a power shift away from the Jed/Trent/Paraag trio that has strangled the organization in so many ways in recent seasons. But that’s what this team needs.

70 Comments

Leave a Reply

70 Comments on "How to bring the 49ers back …"

Notify of
avatar
 
smilegrinwinkmrgreenneutraltwistedarrowshockunamusedcooleviloopsrazzrollcryeeklolmadsadexclamationquestionideahmmbegwhewchucklesillyenvyshutmouth
Photo and Image Files
 
 
 
Audio and Video Files
 
 
 
Other File Types
 
 
 
Sort by:   newest | oldest | most voted
thelobster22
Guest
Member
thelobster22

BASportsGuy ditto on the Huskies. Years of brutal football lead to this year’s bliss

Scott no2
Guest
Member
Scott no2

I don’t like any of those ideas.  My idea is to make Bay Area Sports guy the GM.

Giants55
Guest
Member
Giants55

BASportsGuy remember when Mike Holmgren was interested and Jed was all “nah”

BASportsGuy
Guest
Member
BASportsGuy

Giants55 Yeah, Holmgren said they thought he was too old.

Cody00ss
Guest
Member
Cody00ss

BASportsGuy The Shannahan option makes so much sense. Now I’m going to be disappointed when it doesn’t happen. Thanks.

FredMercuryVest
Guest
Member
FredMercuryVest

BASportsGuy A good read.

highsox
Guest
Member
highsox

Yay Banana Slugs! Also, great analysis, as usual. I wish Jeddy Y listened to you

jchromem
Guest
Member
jchromem

Cody00ss BASportsGuy It really does which is why it’ll never happen.

jstidham1
Guest
Member
jstidham1

BASportsGuy “Gabbsolutely”. That one was brilliant.

nflguy49
Guest
Member
nflguy49

BASportsGuy Only way the last option happens is if Jed is “promoted” to another family Biz venture and away from the Niners.

jonny_nor_cal
Guest
Member
jonny_nor_cal

BASportsGuy good read, thanks

Ikeyo_1985
Guest
Member
Ikeyo_1985

BASportsGuy Hiring the Shanahans, bringing in an experienced staff, having York stay away from the Football side?…Santa isn’t real, BASG.

AdamWright1
Guest
Member
AdamWright1

Great post, as usual. Steve, we need you posting more frequently, more than ever, right now. Pressure needs to be exerted on ownership, and right now I’m afraid that indifference is winning over anything.

grantcohn
Guest
Member
grantcohn

jonny_nor_cal No to Shanahan. Yes to Shaw. Saban should be the top target.

ARJones12
Guest
Member
ARJones12

grantcohn jonny_nor_cal – Saban won’t get respect amongst NFL players base of Miami. Walsh called Urban Meyer the vanguard of coaches.

jonny_nor_cal
Guest
Member
jonny_nor_cal

grantcohn would love Shaw

TAvery88
Guest
Member
TAvery88

BASportsGuy Go full Shanahan. Option I have wanted since Harbaugh. Respect the past not the 86 NY Giants.

grantcohn
Guest
Member
grantcohn

jonny_nor_cal the Shanahans are system coaches who can’t develop QBs.

BASportsGuy
Guest
Member
BASportsGuy

jstidham1 It’s no Tomsulery, but it works with certain throws.

Barber2910
Guest
Member
Barber2910

BASportsGuy rid of baalke and York.

tkwill49
Guest
Member
tkwill49

BASportsGuy I like Steve Young in an Elway role. Young is so darn competitive

IttaiShay
Guest
Member
IttaiShay

YR195 BASportsGuy I’m not willing to share Joe just yet. Let the Warriors win 5 more championships first.

laughlikeahyena
Guest
Member
laughlikeahyena

BASG 2020: Make the 49ers Great Again

44Stretchisbest
Guest
Member
44Stretchisbest

Cody00ss BASportsGuy No…hate to mix things, but an unabashed trump supporter as coach would be end of me being 49ers fan

Cody00ss
Guest
Member
Cody00ss

44Stretchisbest I didn’t realize he was. When did he come out as a Trump supporter?

44Stretchisbest
Guest
Member
44Stretchisbest
irishman217
Guest
Member
irishman217

Cody00ss BASportsGuy my sentiments exactly

Beaver
Guest
Member
Beaver

As long as the Niners can keep lulling the other team into prevent defense, they already have an Pro Bowl QB.

Cody00ss
Guest
Member
Cody00ss

44Stretchisbest Ugh

44Stretchisbest
Guest
Member
44Stretchisbest

Cody00ss yeah, I try to keep real life separate from sports/entertainment…But some things can’t be ignored…

jthussle_32
Guest
Member
jthussle_32

grantcohn jonny_nor_cal The RG3 offense in Washington and Kyle’s offense in Atlanta aren’t remotely the same.

Cody00ss
Guest
Member
Cody00ss

44Stretchisbest Agreed. On to unrealistic option number 15.

AdamWright1
Guest
Member
AdamWright1

nflguy49 BASportsGuy Is there a realistic chance of this happening? And any chance at all of the Yorks selling? We always hear that there’s no chance at all; is this really true?

GoPrayogo
Guest
Member
GoPrayogo

bimski one personnel guy from Patriots is worthy of a GM position, the name escape atm.

coredump
Guest
Member
coredump
BASportsGuy Giants55  Holmgren indeed maybe too old, and that even might be the reason he thought he wasn’t hired, but I doubt it’s the only reason. I’d also expect that Baalke wouldn’t want him, because Holmgren has a football legacy already, and wouldn’t be intimidated (nor presumably controlled) by Baalke as the GM.  Nor would Holmgren feel obligated to pay homage to lil Jed on bended knee. I.e. back to the oft-repeated theory:  no coach who has other options would willingly come to the York-Baalke niners.  Removing Baalke (assuming that even happens) might, *might* make the position more palatable for some,… Read more »
coredump
Guest
Member
coredump
I’m a Bay Area sports fan, so I root for the Giants & A’s, and the Niners & Raiders.  Obviously it’s been a lot more fun watching the Raiders and the Giants than the A’s and the Niners, and probably for at least some of the same/similar reasons. Same/similar formula as the W’s — ownership getting good management, and good management getting good players and coaches.  I’m not saying it’s all the same for all the successful local teams, but I think it’s fair to say that on-field success starts off the field. I don’t think the Yorks have worked… Read more »
bimski
Guest
Member
bimski

Nick Caserio? He’s Pioli’s padawan, if we can go with the master, why not? GoPrayogo

fact275
Guest
Member
fact275

BASportsGuy You know it’s gonna be 2

Aclarkcomedy
Guest
Member
Aclarkcomedy

BASportsGuy Full Shanahan and they get Cousins

jav95_
Guest
Member
jav95_

jerodbrown62 the Shanahan solution would be really nice

DenverDrew44
Guest
Member
DenverDrew44

BASportsGuy good article BASG! Makes sense, so Jed will just fire Trent and promote Gamble because that’s #PureYork

coredump
Guest
Member
coredump

fact275 BASportsGuy  Yeah, 1 or 2 are probably the ways to bet it.  How dismal.

ATLat23
Guest
Member
ATLat23

BASportsGuy has to start with the overhaul non player personnel.

sixxfigga
Guest
Member
sixxfigga

BASportsGuy i like it man. Its actually what i wanted them to try and do before tomsula was hired.

Swipesterr
Guest
Member
Swipesterr

BASportsGuy
Clean house upstairs!

thepepperlanders
Guest
Member
thepepperlanders

The York’s would have to spend money to change this team.  NOT GOING TO HAPPEN !!!

thepepperlanders
Guest
Member
thepepperlanders

Read an article about mommy York bragging that she found a lamp or something for only $24 bucks.  She’s worth what? A billion or so? Thats like someone worth a million bragging that they found something worth a dime for only 3 cents. You think someone like that is going to spend dough that they don’t have to spend?  The 49ers are the Walmart team of professional sports until fans stop payment on season tickets. Which means fans should dump this team and start following the Raiders or some other team.

Otis Byrd III
Guest
Member
Otis Byrd III

jonny_nor_cal grantcohn Shaw would be great, but he’s never going to leave Stanford.

BASportsGuy
Guest
Member
BASportsGuy

MylesInSF If you keep Kelly, who’s the GM? Gamble? Someone else who allows Jed to keep Chip? A strong GM want his own head coach.

fraser_lawrie
Guest
Member
fraser_lawrie

BASportsGuy MylesInSF starting to think baalke/chip both stay..

wpDiscuz
What is Bay Area Sports Guy?

It is the top independent sports site covering the teams that play in the best sports region in the United States. BASG is not an ordinary fan blog. It is a place where sports news is broken and analyzed by writers with access who are not afraid to question the status quo, writers who also produce original content in the form of videos, photographs and podcasts.

Questions/Comments? Email basg@bayareasportsguy.com
Fill out my online form.

Copyright © 2017 - Bay Area Sports Guy. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy Terms of Use and BASG Shop Terms

To Top