The exploits of one William Lamar “Billy” Beane need no introduction. His successes have been chronicled in everything from blogs (yes, even this one) to movies starring Brad Pitt.
In essence, he is to Major League Baseball what Bob Saget is to family-friendly television. Which is to say, despite being terribly miscast in his role, Beane finds a way to make it all work. After all, what are the odds that a hot-tempered major league burnout would find a way to eschew fickle emotion for analytical wherewithal?
Consider this year’s success in comparison to a comparable team like the San Diego Padres:
The A’s have the second-lowest payroll in baseball, trailing the San Diego Padres only by a couple hundreds of thousands. While the Padres’ payroll sunk the team to a .458 winning percentage, the A’s have flourished: They are 14 games over .500 for the first time since 2006. What’s more, the A’s have the eighth-hardest schedule in baseball, while the Padres have the eighth-easiest.
There may be no better illustration of the Beane’s steely dealings than this past offeason. Beane traded away three of the most prominent, fan-adored A’s. The knee-jerk reaction to these deals was to assume Beane was selling off the team in preparation to move to San Jose, or wherever. Au contraire: Beane was creating a contender.
The trades of Gio Gonzalez, Andrew Bailey, and Trevor Cahill yielded Jarrod Parker and Tommy Milone, both of whom have WARs above 2.0, as well as All-Star Ryan Cook and Derrick Norris. Perhaps the biggest acquisition was that of Josh Reddick, who leads the team in home runs, RBIs, walks, and WAR.
No other GM could have done this. They would have all given to the pressures of public perception, or of the human element. For most general managers, like Brian Sabean, baseball is a game about people and inevitably emotion.
“Building your club is also about relationships and communication,” said Sabean, general manager of the San Francisco Giants. “We all know how to use statistics and all know how to use analysis to make an educated decision and look forward, but should it — or does it — rule the day? In my opinion, I don’t think so. I think most people would admit you need it, but there’s a feel that goes along with it.’’
But for Beane, baseball is game about players, not people. Focusing on the human aspect leads to the pratfalls of the Aaron Rowands, the Aubrey Huffs, and the Barry Zitos. Maintaining statistical objectivity has allowed Beane to accrue a winning percentage of .533, just three one-hundredths of a point lower than Sabean’s, who has enjoyed payrolls as much as two times the amount of Beane’s. In short, it has allowed Beane to be better than the rest.














49ers Hot Read
49ersnews.com
49erswebzone.com
Niner Insider
Athletics Nation
95.7 FM The Game
Bay Area Sports Talk
Popblerd
Ray Ratto – CSNBA
Ruthless Sports
Giants Extra
Giants Talk
Giants365.com
GiantsPod
Optioned to Fresno
Fangraphs
Pro Football Talk
Feltbot's Warriors Blog
Joe Lacob & Co. [libelous slander]
WarriorsCentral.com

Well since this article was written Sabes won the World Series for the second time in three years. Ill take his resume over Beane. Also, OAKLAND is in the Bay Area... Stop calling them a small market! They have a minimal budget yes, but that's self imposed. OAKLAND has too many down years for me to put Beane in the elite GM category. He's made some REALLY bad moves as well! Andre Ethier, Carlos Gonzalez, and keeping Eric Chavez.
Marty Lurie was asked on radio..I missed most of the beginning I just heard "He's a very smart man,in a no lose position. Sabean,has always put his reputation on the line". True..if BEANE wins..he's available for all interviews..when they lose? He cant be found and the A's media blames the fans or Oakland or the weather.. And we see why Beane couldn't handle another GM job. He's got nothing to lose here.
I enjoy the A's have a great season as well as anybody else..A better record then the Giants on Sept 1st? AND the Giants are in first place?. I revel..but I know the Beane mind too.
This blog never talked A's until me..now,they talk A's like straight out of the A's media room! Good thing they have me to keep it real. Very real.
Imagine what he could do with a $100mil budget. Still have a payroll of $50mil.
Don't you get it? He will NEVER have a 100 million dollar budget because Beane the part owner wont spend that amount. THAT'S the whole problem with the A's...THEY limit themselves..not OAKLAND or the Coloseum. THE A's are the money cheap ones ones making the decisions.
Actually, being at the Coliseum doesn't limit their revenue.
And one thing about Beane..he loves the credit..but when he's wrong he NEVER admits it. Like Bush,he cant think of any mistakes he's made..
I think what he is best at..is getting the media to say he's the best. NO other GM who won nothing but a division would ever be called "best","greatest".
What JR Sm said. World Series titles can't be the only measure of one's success. If that were the case, then you'd have to concede to the A's being superior franchise as the Giants have won only 6 titles to the A's' 9. You'd also then need to concede that Ozzie Guillen is as good a manager as Bobby Cox and Bruce Bochy.
I think a lot of people in this forum are giving Sabean too much credit. I'm a Giants fan, and Beane has a much tougher road to get to in the World Series (going through NY and BOS in the past decade). Not to mention Billy's budget is much, much smaller than SF's budget. Not to mention Sabean couldn't figure out how to win the Series with one of the greatest players ever (even if he was juicing).
If you swallow beanaide..sure. The rest of us know that the A's are full of money,and if those rich guys thought the A's were a money loser franchise they would sell in a heartbeat. Beane this year made his own arguments a lie.
That explains a certain media personality and his love of Billy Beane.
On the other hand.to get credentials from the A's its well known-you cant criticize Beane.
Hey Stan, since it's well known, how about naming someone denied a credential after criticizing Beane.
Me. Now,aren't you the big ass?
Stan, we are talking about media credentials. What does Gene Simmons have to do with this? He's not a member of the media. You think the only way he could gets into Dodger games, paying or otherwise, is with a media credential? Andy Dolich isn't a member of the media. Why would he be entitled to a media credential? Why is there any reason to believe he ever was denied a media credential?
And Andy Dolich..a vip and lover of the A's..has to pay his way in. You think Gene Simmons pays to see the Dodgers..or is he a guest of Gruber?.
Rich Leiberman.
Stan, so what you're saying is you don't know of any actual cases of legitimate professional writers who were denied a credential after criticizing Beane.
So,based on that Reg,I deduce that BASG would get nowhere bashing Beane and Wolff. But I think a rational conclusion..don't you?
Well Mike Urban said on THEGAME that Billy Beane made it clear..if you criticize him,you will find it hard to get access to the A's players and coaches. Now,if you want to call Urban a liar..that's up to you.
What I meant was people who actually work in the media, professional writers. Major League teams don't normally hand out credentials to unqualified amateurs. Can you name any professional writers who were denied a credential after criticizing Beane? I understand that people
TSL about covered it. Its asinine to call him the "best" when he hasn't even sniffed a single World Series,while Sabean has two trips and one ultimate-World Champs. Was he the best when the A's finished last back to back years? And ask Geo and the Nats who got the better of that trade..Billy has been boosted by the best scouting system in baseball..and the many,many former A's starring on other teams means Beane has been easy pickings by the other GM's. How many stars have the Giants traded away?
B.S...has a Billy Beane GM'd team won a World Series. Sabes has blundered but he has 2010. Case closed.
Shouldn't we be talking about Sabes being the best GM in baseball? Sabes has led the Giants to two world series with two different managers and two completed teams. The Giants have also had 4 straight winning seasons. When was the last time the Beane did that? Sabes also has to deal with higher expectations. Many people were predicting the Giants to win the division and the A's to finish in last place. Its easy to succeed if the bar is set low. To go with those higher expectations, the Giants play in the superior league. Look at all the great teams that the Giants have to face in the NL - The Dodgers, Reds, Nationals, Pirates, etc. And lets not forget that the Giants did win 4 of 6 from the A's this year.
I think "Moneyball" should have won an Oscar.
East Bay Sports Guy. Are you serious? Billy Beane is easily the most overrated GM in baseball. The current record does not count. Purely an abboration. I enjoy the A's as much as anyone else, but look at this objectively, and Brian Sabian is the choice as best GM in baseball. Who else has done so much with so little. Three managers in 20 years and one World Series ring. How many managers has Billy Beane gone through? How many World Series rings does Billy have? Case closed.
Ironically I fell asleep watching Moneyball last night and it gets better every time I watch it. As a rabid Giants fan, I'm actually jealous of the A's having Beane and his amazing track record. I certainly root for the A's when they're not playing the Giants and am always in awe of their success despite such limited resources. You reference the selloff this past offseason and it's identical to the season featured in Moneyball when everyone thought they were sellers after unloading Jeremy Giambi and Carlos Pena. You also reference the "feel" approach that Sabean feels is necessary and killing that outdated approach was the hurdle Beane couldn't convince the oldtimer scouts to get over. Beane has revolutionized the entire industry (all the new stats at our disposal are due to him lending more credence to the Bill James formulas) and stayed put in small market Oakland. Now if he can turn the crapshoot of the postseason his direction he'll finally get the respect he so truly deserves. On an unrelated side note, I was mentioning to my wife this morning just how worthless Moneyball made Art Howe appear. There's resistance to change, and then there's just plain ignorant stubbornness! Howe wasn't happy with that portrayal but it has to be somewhat accurate to be so blatant. Rematch of the 1989 World Series anyone? Skip the quake this time...
It would be quite something to see what Beane would actually do with an open checkbook.
Did you write this just for Stan? ;) I think he's a very good GM, who gets a lot of undue credit and undue flack. I trust his judgement in building a team. It's hard to call any MLB GM "best" due to the huge sliding scale in terms of economic resources, market pressures, etc.
Agreed Nice article by the way. Totally right about Sabeans penchant for being too emotional in his decision making process. Case in point- Beltran for Zach Wheeler trade who is projected to be a number one ace starter. Beane would never have made that move.