If there’s a silver lining to the Sharks’ 3-1 loss to the Dallas Stars on Saturday night, it’s that the SAP Open road trip is finally over and the team is headed back home. Beyond that, there’s nothing of value to pull from the defeat. Sure, the penalty kill was solid yet again and Antti Niemi continued to be the only reason why San Jose even hung around, but holding your opponents to two tallies a night won’t help you win when you can’t put up three of your own. The Sharks’ signature over the last several years was their offense, but now it’s gone and the fundamental problems with the team remain the reason why they’re stuck in the mud yet again.
The Sharks’ issues run deeper than just scoring. Every team sport is connected like an infinity symbol, with one loop feeding off of the other. While the defense has been solid protecting it’s own end, it hasn’t been strong moving the puck into the attack. Teams have been clogging up the Sharks in the neutral zone, and when entries fall flat there’s no hope of setting up and scoring. The offense needs the defense if it has any hope, and yet the defense needs the offense if the Sharks want to be anything more than a .500 team.
What’s even more alarming is how the Sharks’ effort has waned. A small handful of players appear more and more frustrated with the team’s failure, and even fewer are handling it well. While Ryane Clowe is watching the game on the couch and waiting for his discipline hearing, Joe Thornton is the only Shark willing to drop the gloves and tell his team to get it together with his fists. It puts the team’s most valuable scorer in the penalty box serving fighting majors while the Sharks miss the message, surrendering momentum from the fight to their opponent.
The team as a whole appears to lose energy and a willingness to battle when things don’t go their way. There’s a disconnect, with players either playing out of their roles or not living up to them. The captain has been the spark twice on this road trip, while players like Adam Burish take up important on-ice minutes and secede offensive possessions. The fundamental aspects of hockey — the type of things teams like the Stars or Blue Jackets do well in beating the Sharks — are exactly the tasks seemingly above some of the Sharks players. It’s too early in the season to be tired. It’s too early in the season to give up. And yet it’s the only way to describe the way this team is playing: tired and submissive.
The hot start the Sharks got off to in January wasn’t entirely a facade. This team has talent. It could certainly use some more — the third and fourth lines are scoring anemically and even moving Thornton to the second line couldn’t help Martin Havlat find his way — and they still may add some before the trading deadline in April. It’s just hard to picture the Sharks suddenly finding their stride simply by returning to the comfy confines of The Tank. The answers to the team’s problems don’t simply lie in familiar zip codes.
I wondered aloud before this season began whether Todd McLellan would be on the hot seat. He’s been one of the most successful regular season coaches in hockey since coming to San Jose, but then that’s always been the rub on the Sharks, hasn’t it? Regular season champions. They even have a banner for it hanging in the rafters at HP Pavilion. The guys insisted McLellan’s job would be safe, but at this point I’m not so sure anyone’s job with the Sharks is safe. Big changes could be coming, and they may start with the man behind the bench.
McLellan has altered just about every aspect of the team that could possibly be altered. All of the line juggling and AHL call-ups have been like Band Aids in a bathtub. providing momentary fixes before ultimately proving to be no match against an even larger problem. No, the solution has to go above McLellan’s head now, in the form of a major trade or a head coaching change. There’s talent still to be utilized on the San Jose Sharks, but as the team stands now, it’s wasting away.














49ers Hot Read
49ersnews.com
49erswebzone.com
Niner Insider
Athletics Nation
95.7 FM The Game
Bay Area Sports Talk
Popblerd
Ray Ratto – CSNBA
Ruthless Sports
Giants Extra
Giants Talk
Giants365.com
GiantsPod
Optioned to Fresno
Fangraphs
Pro Football Talk
Feltbot's Warriors Blog
Joe Lacob & Co. [libelous slander]
WarriorsCentral.com

The Sharks have gone to the playoffs every season under Wilson's tenure. Unfortunately, I believe that fact will be why Wilson continues to be the GM. What I don't think will be taken into account is how Wilson has depleted the farm system by trading away top picks for rental players like Guerin and Campbell. When you draft as poorly as the Sharks, you just can't give away top picks for rentals. Yes, they got Pavs, Braun, and Demers in the 7th round but look at 2003 in the first round. They took Michalek over Ryan Suter, Brent Seabrook, Jeff Carter, Brent Burns and Dustin Brown. Also in the first round of 2003, they took Steve Bernier over Zach Parise, Ryan Getzlaf, Ryan Kesler, and Corey Perry. In the 2nd round, they took Josh Hennessey when they could have had Patrice Bergeron. Also in that round, in what might be one of the top 5 screw-ups for DW, the Sharks took Matt Carle over Shea Weber! This is just in 2003. Would any Sharks fan today take Burns for Setoguchi, Coyle, and a 1st found pick? Didn't think so. As I said though, I think the ownership will simply look at playoff appearances rather than digging deep. Also, has anyone seen the new realignment schemes? While I agree there should be SOME realignment, not sure I agree with this. It's clearly stupid that Dallas is a Pacific team while Vancouver isn't. However, I think more focus needs to be put on scheduling to even things out. How many times have we seen the Sharks start on a road trip to LA, then go to St. Louis only to come back to play Anaheim or Phoenix?
I agree with you in principle, though I'm not big on second guessing drafts in any sport, generally too easy to look at in hindsight. Michalek turned into a pretty decent player, not a complete bust. I don't remember back then if that pick was considered a good/bad one at the time. As far as the Burns trade goes, I'm still not really penning that as a success or failure yet. From what we've seen of him healthy, a puck mover who can create from the blue line is much more valuable than Setoguchi, Coyle and a pick. If that ones a failure, it'll be more because of his health than his ability. With that said, I'll gladly roast Wilson for many, many of his trades where we didn't even come close to getting good value. McGinn is an obvious one. Prospects and McGinn for two players who were mediocre at best? Then there's the Heatley for Havlat trade, which is still somewhat mitigated by the salary difference. Then there's getting virtually nothing for Ehrhoff, trading a second rounder for shitty Dominic Moore, and the list goes on and on. I think the Burns trade still has a decent chance of working out in our favor, but there's no lack of ones to point to in just the last few years that have been clear stinkers. Draft-wise, we have zero players since the 2009 draft that are on our pro squad. ZERO. We're the only team in the league that can say that. Wilson's time to go has come, because right now the only way this mess is going to get cleaned up is by taking some serious steps back and start rebuilding our prospect pool from the ground up. I want him gone because I think he'll be looking for quick fixes and further degrade the assets we still have.
You would expect that when your GM was an all star D-man, he would better at assessing defensive talent, but instead we end up with guys named Petrecki, Wishart, Wallin, and Colin White.
I completely agree with your article Ruthless. The team quit on McClellan last year and he hasn't gotten them back. It looks like all the playoff losses this core suffered together has finally beat them. McClellan doesn't have the resume or charisma to get them back. No better time than now. I'd like to see what Wilson can get for the high-profile, high-value talent he's put together before getting rid of him. He's earned the opportunity to put together a new team. He's put together a few teams that were good enough to win it all. Nabby was my favorite player (loved him hated him) and I was ready to watch him go but they REALLY miss his leadership right now. Of course Niemi is a better goalie at this point in their careers but I think Nabby had a very brash and effective leadership quality that the locker room lacks now. We all know of his ultra-intense competitiveness. To the point of being a complete asshole sometimes. No one else seems to have taken on that role. It's a shame the Sharks haven't played in a Cup but they could turn this around. Like Fitz points out above... there are some good young hockey players on the team. And Boyle, Stuart, Vlasic, Braun are a plenty good 4-D. Just need more energy, more speed, more creativity up front.
The point I was going to make has been stresse plenty in the comments already. Doug Wilson needs to be held accountable. The Sharks don't have much talent in the pipeline because of all his mid-season deals that not only haven't led to Stanley Cups, but don't normally lead to the acquisitions signing with the Sharks afterwards. The Burns trade is looking worse as time goes on (tell me we couldn't use Setoguchi right now). It easy to say McClellan needs to go, but who are you going to bring in that better? Firing coaches every five years and keeping the same front office isn't working for the Sharks.
This may not be the most popular notion, but I think its time for Doug Wilson to go. I had season tickets for years, all through the 2000's, and although playoff hockey is maybe the best live fan experience ever, the Sharks layed an egg every year. They had a window where the should have won it all, but they were never able to round out their roster with the guys needed to get the cup. You could see it every season...the flawed defensive players, the big trade for the guy that backfired, too much pressure on Marleau and Thornton locking them up when the heat was on. The best thing I have EVER seen live in sports was a 5 on 3 power play, where only 1 Shark had a stick, and the Sharks fought it off. The worst was watching this team come up small in big series, after big series in the playoffs, and now seeing them look like a bunch of stiffs after a hot start. I think the core knows their window shut in their faces.
They can't and will never win a cup witj Marleau. DW and Tmac both need to be fired after season if not now. They need to rebuild the roster with different characters.
Time to pack up pickles and Murray and make some moves. The team lacks energy and moving those two may send a wake up call.
Pickles? Why would we move one of our youngest and best d-men in our own end? He's not an offensive force, but tell me if there's very many guys in hockey you'd take having to play a 2-1 or a 3-1 situation? Guy can handle going up against elite forwards and still come out ahead in +/- and better metrics that indicate how well he's playing. Murray, absolutely in favor or moving, he's been a huge liability handling the puck and outside of a few hits and blocked shots hasn't done a whole lot to help this team. Too old and slow.
Pickles because he holds a lot of value for being a great player. Team needs to get some talent and you need to give to get.
Unless you're going for a scorched earth rebuild, that's not a good idea at all. The youngest and best are the ones you want to hold on to, because they'll be around still when you're ready for another run. Also, Vlasic's contract is relatively cheap compared to the kind of value he brings to the table, definitely a good piece to build around. McLellen or whoever is coach just needs to have the sense to pair him with Burns or someone who can move the puck well, because that's not his strong suit.
don't know if i would just blame murray for the horrendous powerplay.
I don't think TMac is the problem although he'll probably become the scapegoat for the current woes of team teal. For me, it starts at the the top. Prior to Wilson becoming GM, the Sharks may not have been winning as much, but least they were nasty and feared. Wilson has come in and signed guys who apparently aren't judged by heart or effort but merely by their character and "hockey IQ". I guess you don't have to have fire or will, as long as you understand the game. While Wilson has made a couple of successful deals like Thornton and Boyle, he's given up tons of top draft picks for rentals like Campbell and Guerin who never panned out. With any luck, the new ownership will see that Wilson's "remain calm, all is well" attitude is outdated and needs a change. If you want an omelette, you have to break some eggs.
I think it's time for Wilson to go unless he can reinvent himself as the overnight rebuilder. He's done a great job keeping the window open for a year or two more at a time, but at this point it's clear anymore of that is damaging the future and won't keep the window open. I felt the window showed itself as closed last year, but this year is proving that. This is not an elite team anymore and anymore attempts to make trades, reload, etc is just going to make the rebuilding that much harder. It kills me, but it's time to bite the bullet and start stockpiling some young talent. The cupboard isn't bare, we have Vlasic, Burns, Couture, Pavelski, Braun and Demers to build around. Love Thornton, Marleau, Boyle, etc, but it's time to get younger and that probably means most if not all of them will be moving on.
Yeah I say you make a move in the offseason AND fire Doug Wilson. The Sharks had that criticial 2 year window a couple of years ago to win it all. They did not. At this point, Wilson has been building around aging stars whose prime (as a group) has passed them by. Once you get a new GM in there with a different philosophy, THEN you let him evaluate Todd and the 'veterans' and let him start making moves accordingly.