Joe Pavelski

Rick Nash to the Sharks? Probably not

By Guest Contributor Kyle McLorg

Twitter came alive yesterday with chatter regarding the San Jose Sharks trading to acquire Columbus Blue Jackets forward Rick Nash. My buddy suggested I write something about it, but I swore to myself I wouldn’t until I has some solid ground to stand on.

At this point though, the rumors regarding Nash have gotten too big for me to ignore.

The Blue Jackets, at 17-34-6, are in the middle of a nightmare season and are said to be shopping Nash, their star left right wing, in hopes of beginning the rebuilding process. Nash, in his third ninth full year with the club, has 18 goals and 21 assists and would certainly be a game-changing addition should the Sharks trade to acquire him. The question is — at what cost?

Don’t get too excited — the price might be to steep. According to Pierre LeBrun of ESPN, several teams are in the mix for Nash, most notably the Canucks, Flyers, Rangers and Kings. LeBrun named the Sharks as a wild card team in terms of acquiring Nash, along with the St. Louis Blues.

Should Rick Nash be traded before the trade deadline of February 27th, he would be the hottest commodity in the NHL. The demand is high, so the Blue Jackets stand to get a hefty package in return; something that perhaps would be too cost prohibitive for San Jose.

Columbus would likely demand not only a goal tender, but also a playmaking skater or two in return for Nash. The Sharks certainly have depth at goalie — with Thomas Griess as the favorite trade bait — considering that they have a solid starter in Antti Niemi as well as Alex Stalock and Tyson Sexsmith waiting in the wings. But the next name that would be called from the Sharks, as Ray Ratto of CSN Bay Area pointed out on Chronicle Live last night, would most likely be Joe Pavelski. The Dudes On Hockey agree.

Pavelski has been the breakout star for the Sharks this year with 22 goals and 22 assists. He has flourished playing with the Sharks’ top skaters this year and is probably the most valuable player on the roster; too valuable to be used in a trade package, regardless of who the Sharks would get in return. Given the chemistry and playmaking skills that Pavelski provides, Doug Wilson probably won’t be willing to part ways with him.

The next name on the list is Patrick Marleau. Marleau’s name has been mentioned more often by speculative fans than expert analysts, but the Sharks’ franchise player is an intriguing option. He has the regular season numbers to provoke trade interest. On the same token, Marleau has been a playoff underachiever, giving the Sharks reason to consider pawning him off for a better post-season asset. Chances are this probably won’t happen, though — sentiment surround Marleau is too high, both in Sharks fans’ hearts as well as Doug Wilson’s. That’s all without mentioning the no-trade clause in Marleau’s contract, an obstacle that may close the door on this option.

Given the package of talent that acquiring Nash will command, it seems unlikely that the Sharks will pull this trade off. All the interest surrounding him, however, should serve the Sharks well. It may help them slide under the radar and acquire a few pieces to help down the final stretch towards to the playoffs.

You can find more of Kyle McLorg’s writing at Ruthless Sports. Follow him on Twitter @Ruthless_Sports.


Leave a Reply

4 Comments on "Rick Nash to the Sharks? Probably not"

Photo and Image Files
Audio and Video Files
Other File Types
newest oldest most voted
Notify of
Taylor Green
Taylor Green
I clicked this since you happened to be the top link on google when I searched “Rick Nash Sharks” to find any NEWS regarding the situation. Instead I got a random summation of stuff that didn’t make any sense. Rick Nash is a RIGHT winger who was drafted first overall in the 2002 draft playing his NINTH full season with the club and has been their captain for the past four seasons. Then you spouted out random heresay from a roundtable discussion forum without delving at all into the topic. You also fail to mention that the Sharks are notrious… Read more »
Taylor Green
Taylor Green
The cap hit is the only conceivable reason this trade couldn’t happen, and that’s why someone like Martin Havlat or Marc-Eduard Vlasic will be involved to cushion some of that salary. Would losing Vlasic hurt? Yes, obviously. But it’s not a team altering move like trading Pavelski or Marleau. It’s along the lines of trading Stuart, Setoguchi, Ehrhoff, Cheechoo, etc. who have been involved in trades like this before. As for your comment on the Burns trade, all three of those pieces were completely expendable. Brodie Coyle is a project first rounder who probably didn’t have a huge place on… Read more »
Alex Dunhill
Alex Dunhill
I miss having Seto on the team because he shined pretty bright for us and that was a hard loss. SJS can lessen their sacrifices for Nash by putting Niemi on the table. Nemo is Nabby 2.0 without actually being an improvement. Nemo’s price is the only reason why he is starting and I think SJS royally messed up when they acquired him. Remember when J-S Giggy was supposed to be unstoppable because of one great season and a remarkable playoff? I think a Thomas-Antero rotation in goal is better for SJ and Niemi still has an allure. We don’t… Read more »
What is Bay Area Sports Guy?

It is the top independent sports site covering the teams that play in the best sports region in the United States. BASG is not an ordinary fan blog. It is a place where sports news is broken and analyzed by writers with access who are not afraid to question the status quo, writers who also produce original content in the form of videos, photographs and podcasts.

Questions/Comments? Email
Fill out my online form.

Copyright © 2017 - Bay Area Sports Guy. All rights reserved. Privacy Policy Terms of Use and BASG Shop Terms

To Top